2024

Historia Slavorum Occidentis

Rocznik: 2024 | Tom: 42 | Numer: 3

artykuł naukowy

polski

EN For the author of the book presented below, the topic of Slavic beliefs is only a pretext for formulating writing technique-related postulates. A discussion with D.A. Sikorski should not take place in the field of methodology, or the field of the substance, and even less in the field of extra-academic research motivations. A historian should give voice to the source accounts (which does not necessarily mean considering them historically reliable), and this is made possible by appropriate methods. D.A. Sikorski, on the other hand, believes that the method is secondary, as long as it leads to results that are consistent with the ‘state of the facts’, which in practice have nothing to do with the sources. His proposal, however, is unacceptable for it is characterised by unreliability, one-sidedness, undermining of source testimony and replacing it with one’s own fantasies in accordance with a preconceived thesis that „it is not known how it actually was, but it is known that the Slavs did not have their own beliefs”. The result is a methodological trap: positivism has been taken to its ultimate consequences and turned upside down, becoming voluntarism within which you can undermine whatever you see fit.

231 - 251

10.15804/hso240308

https://doi.org/10.15804/hso240308

CC BY-NC-ND (uznanie autorstwa - użycie niekomercyjne - bez utworów zależnych)

inne

ostateczna wersja opublikowana

10.2024

w momencie opublikowania

100